Answers

  • Les Kaufman
    Les Kaufman

    Les Kaufman

    • United States of America
    • Marine Biology
    • BOSTON UNIVERSITY
    • 0 followers

    Les Kaufman replied 3rd Aug '15:

    On matters of the nature of the world and how things work, scientific agreement is proportional to the volume and quality of evidence that is available. Lots of good data, lots of agreement on what they mean.

    If the question concerns a choice or action to be taken, on issues of huge importance to the world today, such as mass extinction, climate change, overpopulation and and inequity,
    agreement is very strong. As soon as we enter the spheres of strictly societal and individual human concerns other than health, agreement may weaken. The difficulties of studying human behavior cast a shroud over our understanding of and agreement about how people come to act as they do. Even here, however, in that subset of natural science called "social science" when objective analysis is possible, replication and agreement can soon follow.

    Also, wherever we leave the domain of evidence-based reasoning, we also cross out of science altogether, and hence away from.opportunities for independent verification, the basis for agreement in science.

Comments

Reset my details